The Barmen Declaration of 1934 - When the Church said Jesus is Lord—not Hitler

The Barmen Declaration of 1934 is one of the most important Christian documents of the twentieth century because it was written at a moment when the German church was being pressured to surrender its identity to the Nazi state.

The so-called “German Christians” (Deutsche Christen) were trying to blend Christianity with Nazi racial ideology, recasting Jesus as Aryan, attacking the Old Testament as too Jewish, and presenting loyalty to Hitler as compatible with loyalty to Jesus. In response, leaders of what became known as the “Confessing Church,” especially Karl Barth and Martin Niemöller, pushed back. Barth became the principal author of the declaration, and at its heart was a very simple conviction: Jesus the Messiah alone is Lord of the Church.

What makes Barmen so significant is that it refused to allow the State, race, nationalism, or political ideology to become a second source of revelation alongside Messiah. That may sound obvious today (or maybe not in some circles), but in Germany in 1934 it was anything but obvious. The declaration rejected the idea that the Church should take its direction from “other events and powers, figures and truths” in addition to Jesus. In other words, Hitler did not get to define Christianity. The State did not get to rewrite the Gospel. The Church belonged to Jesus, not to the nation.

DIDN’T ADDRESS JEWISH PERSECUTION

Barmen was not without flaws, and neither was the Confessing Church. It failed to confront antisemitism as clearly as it should have, and much of its resistance focused more on shielding the Church from Nazi control than on defending Jewish people from persecution. Of course, by 1934 the full scale of Nazi atrocities against Jews had not yet unfolded. But even in later years, they were silent.

The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum puts it quite plainly: “With few exceptions the Confessing Church remained silent about the persecution of German Jews.” Still, Barmen drew a line that some Christians refused to cross.

PRE-ORDER RON’S NEW BOOK "THEY TOOK HIS NAME IN VAIN"

AVAILABLE ON KINDLE for $4.99

1000-YEAR REICH… HOW’D THAT WORK OUT?

And history's outcome is striking. Hitler promised a Reich that would last a thousand years. It lasted twelve. The regime that demanded the Church reshape itself around race, blood, and nation collapsed in ruins. The Church is still here. The Gospel is still here. Jesus is still Lord. And he is still Jewish, despite efforts from the German Christians to cut out everything Jewish from the narrative of Jesus, which included “removing the Old Testament from church liturgies, declaring Jesus an Aryan, de-Judaizing the New Testament and hymnal,” writes Professor Susannah Heschel.

That, to me, is one of the great lessons of Barmen. Governments rise and fall. Political movements come and go. Nations can become intoxicated with power. But the Church loses its way the moment it allows any nation, leader, or ideology to tell it who Jesus is or what the Gospel should become.