top of page

How Antisemites Hijacked Romans 9:6

7 minutes ago
9 min read

I have noticed that those in the anti-Israel camp will often not actually debate theology, but simply copy and paste one verse as if that settles the argument. But that is not how we do theology. You don’t make a theological case with one verse—Paul doesn’t do that. And one verse that seems to find its way into the comments section of anything I post online is Romans 9:6: “For not all who are descended from Israel are Israel.”


Replacement theologians and Facebook commenters often point to this verse as evidence that Paul redefined Israel to mean the Church. Under this interpretation, physical descent from Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob no longer carries covenantal significance. The “true Israel” is now the Church, consisting of Jews and Gentiles who believe in Jesus.


But is that what Paul is actually saying? Not when we read his words in context. In fact, the verses immediately following Romans 9:6 tell us precisely what Paul has in mind, and it is not the replacement of Israel by the Church.


Start Where Paul Starts

Before we examine verse 6, we need to understand the emotional intensity of the first five verses. Paul begins Romans 9 by expressing extraordinary anguish over the spiritual condition of his fellow Jewish people. His sorrow is so great that he says he could wish himself cut off from Messiah if that would mean their salvation.


Think about that. Paul is so burdened for the Jewish people that he is willing, hypothetically, to sacrifice his own salvation for theirs. And he makes it absolutely clear whom he is talking about: his “kinsmen according to the flesh” (v. 3 ESV). The NIV says, “those of my own race, the people of Israel.”


He then lists the extraordinary privileges that belong to Israel: the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the giving of the Torah, the worship, the promises, and the patriarchs. He concludes by reminding his readers that Messiah Himself came from the Jewish people according to the flesh. Notice that Paul speaks of these privileges in the present tense. They belong to Israel, not merely belonged to Israel before the coming of Jesus.


Now ask yourself a simple question: Does it make sense that Paul would begin by expressing his willingness to surrender his salvation for Israel, remind us of the promises that still belong to the Jewish people, and then suddenly announce that many of those same Jews are not really Israel at all?


That would be a strange argument. Fortunately, Paul explains himself.


What Does “Not All Israel Is Israel” Actually Mean?

Let’s read the passage beyond verse 6:


“Nor are they all children because they are Abraham’s descendants, but: ‘Through Isaac your descendants will be named’” (Rom. 9:7).

Did you catch that? Paul immediately takes us back to Abraham and his sons. Abraham had more than one son, but God’s covenant promise was specifically established through Isaac, not Ishmael. Paul then continues with the example of Rebecca’s twins, Jacob and Esau. Before either child had been born, God declared that the older would serve the younger. The promise was through Jacob.


Paul’s first illustration is not about some Jewish people being disqualified from their Jewish identity. It is about God’s sovereign choice of the lineage through which His covenant promises would be fulfilled.


Ishmael was Abraham’s son, but he was not Isaac. Esau was Isaac’s son, but he was not Jacob. God’s covenant with the nation of Israel would be established through Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, rather than through every descendant of Abraham. Paul says that God can do that. Paul asks, “Is God unjust? Not at all… it does not … depend on human desire or effort, but on God’s mercy.” (Rom. 9:14, 16). People seem offended that God might still have a special calling on the Jewish nation, but what is that to them? Let God have mercy on whom he wants to have mercy! As Jesus said regarding John the Baptist doubting him, “blessed as he who is not offended on my account” (Matthew 11:6).


This is enormously important because Paul is answering a particular question: If so many Jewish people have not embraced their Messiah, has God’s word to Israel somehow failed?


His answer is an emphatic no! God’s promises have never operated on the principle that every physical descendant of Abraham automatically inherits every aspect of the covenant promise. From the beginning, God sovereignly chose the line through which His purposes would unfold.


And notice something else: Paul does not use Gentile Christians as his examples. He uses Isaac, Ishmael, Jacob, and Esau. His discussion concerns the history of God’s covenant dealings with Abraham’s family. To turn those examples into a declaration that the Church has replaced ethnic Israel is to introduce a conclusion that Paul has not made.


Of course, Paul’s argument does not end with Isaac and Jacob. His opening statement also anticipates the distinction between Israel as a nation and the believing remnant within Israel. But neither distinction eliminates anyone’s Jewish identity. The first explains how God chose the covenant lineage; the second explains why physical descent alone does not guarantee participation in God’s saving promises. Neither teaches that the Church has replaced ethnic Israel.


But There Is Another Important Distinction

Now, we must be careful not to overcorrect. Paul is doing more than explaining why the covenant came through Isaac and Jacob. He is also addressing the difference between belonging to Israel physically and participating in the salvation that God has promised. While Paul is clear that God will still be faithful to the Abrahamic covenant (see Rom. 3:1-4), that covenant was not salvific to one simply by being born Jewish or being circumcised. Salvation is only through Yeshua.


Later in the chapter, Paul quotes Isaiah: “Though the number of the sons of Israel be like the sand of the sea, only the remnant will be saved” (Rom. 9:27).


Here Paul clearly distinguishes between the Jewish nation as a whole and the believing remnant within it. Not every Jewish person is saved simply because he or she is Jewish. A person can belong to Israel ethnically and yet remain alienated from the God of Israel. And rather than being arrogant about that, Paul is broken (refer back to vv. 1-5).


I have always understood Romans 9:6 to be pointing us toward this deeper spiritual reality. The fullest expression of what it means to belong to Israel is not merely having Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in your family tree, but walking in a living relationship with the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. For Paul, that relationship reaches its fulfillment through faith in Israel’s Messiah, Yeshua.


But here is the distinction that must not be missed: A Jewish person who does not believe in Yeshua is still Jewish and still belongs to the people of Israel. Unbelief does not erase ethnicity, ancestry, or national identity.


Indeed, Paul’s argument throughout Romans 9–11 depends upon that very distinction. There is ethnic Israel, and within ethnic Israel there is a believing remnant. The remnant participates in the salvation promised through Messiah, but it does not replace the nation from which it comes. At the end of the age, there will be a great spiritual awakening amongst unbelieving Israel (Rom. 11:25-26).


Paul is not saying that unbelieving Jews are secretly Gentiles or that believing Gentiles have become ethnic Jews, just as he did not mean in Galatians that males become something other than males and females lose their gender after coming to faith (Gal. 3:28), when he is clear that neither race, gender, nor status is connected to salvation. He is explaining how God’s saving purposes operate within Israel and, ultimately, extend to the nations.


Think About the Way We Use Language

Imagine that I travel to Hawaii and taste an extraordinary pineapple, unlike anything I’ve ever experienced. I might turn to my wife and say, “I don’t think I’ve ever tasted real pineapple before!”


Of course, I have eaten pineapple many times. Nobody would understand me to be denying the existence of all the pineapples I had previously eaten. They would understand that I was speaking about pineapple in its fullest, most satisfying expression.


Something similar helps us understand the distinction Paul makes concerning Israel. There is a difference between possessing an identity and experiencing the fullness of what that identity was intended to mean.


The difference, of course, is that Paul is making a serious theological argument, not merely employing a colorful expression. His illustrations of Isaac and Jacob establish the sovereignty of God’s covenant choice, while his discussion of Israel’s unbelief and the faithful remnant establishes that salvation is not guaranteed by physical descent.


The point is not that Jewish people who reject Jesus stop being Jewish. The point is that the highest fulfillment of Israel’s calling is to know and worship the God of Israel through His Messiah.


That distinction is crucial because so many people think that if you hold a position consistent with Scripture, that God’s gift and calling to Israel remains, that you’re somehow denying the need of Jewish people to embrace salvation. Take James Fishback, the white supremacist who ran for governor of Florida recently. When a student at Liberty University asked him about the Jewish people and the church's relationship to them, more than once he responded that there’s no other means of salvation than Jesus. Of course. That wasn’t the question. Is it possible for God to be faithful to his covenant people while also making it clear that eternal salvation is only through his Son?


Otherwise, we end up using Paul’s teaching about salvation to erase the very people whose salvation he so desperately desires.


Romans 11 Settles the Question

If someone still believes Romans 9:6 means ethnic Israel has been replaced, I would encourage that person to continue reading until Romans 11.


Paul asks, “Has God rejected His people?” His answer could hardly be clearer: “By no means!” (Rom. 11:1). He repeats the point in verse 2: “God has not rejected His people whom He foreknew.”


And who are these people? Paul identifies himself as an Israelite, a descendant of Abraham, from the tribe of Benjamin. He uses his own Jewish ancestry as evidence that God has not rejected Israel.


Then Paul employs the illustration of an olive tree. Some of the natural branches have been broken off because of unbelief, while believing Gentiles, described as wild branches, have been grafted in.


But here is what replacement theology cannot adequately explain: Paul continues to call unbelieving Jewish people the natural branches!


Their unbelief has resulted in their being broken off from the olive tree, but it has not changed their identity as the natural branches. Paul does not say they have become something other than Israel. In fact, he explicitly describes the olive tree as their own tree (Rom. 11:24). Their relationship to the nourishing root has been broken through unbelief, but their identity as the natural branches remains. And Paul assures us that God is able to graft them in again through faith (v. 23).


He even warns Gentile believers against arrogance toward those branches. Why would Paul issue such a warning if the Jewish people had permanently forfeited their identity and covenantal significance?


Paul then takes the argument even further. He says that although many in Israel are enemies with respect to the gospel, they remain beloved for the sake of the patriarchs, “for God’s gifts and His calling are irrevocable” (Rom. 11:28–29). Think about the implications. Even in their unbelief, they remain beloved because of the patriarchs. God’s calling has not been revoked, and His promises have not been canceled. If unbelief automatically canceled Israel’s covenantal identity and calling, Paul’s statement that they remain beloved because of the patriarchs and that God's calling is irrevocable would make little sense. If they are no longer connected to the patriarchs, why are they still beloved?


Finally, Paul anticipates a future salvation of Israel, declaring, “And in this way all Israel will be saved” (Rom. 11:26). Everything comes full circle in the end. His ancient covenant people will one day enjoy the fullness of covenant relationship through Jesus. The Gentiles will rejoice. But maybe some will be like the older brother of the prodigal son, angry that the Lord has grafted in the broken-off branches.


Why This Matters Today

The misuse of Romans 9:6 is not simply an academic disagreement. In an age of resurgent antisemitism, some people have taken this verse and weaponized it against the Jewish people.


They argue that since not all Israel is Israel, the Jewish people have lost their unique place in God’s purposes. Some go further, claiming that modern Israel has no biblical significance whatsoever and that the promises of restoration should be understood exclusively in spiritual terms for the Church.


But Paul’s own argument moves in precisely the opposite direction. He begins with anguish over ethnic Israel, explains the sovereignty of God’s covenant promises, distinguishes between the nation and its believing remnant, and concludes by affirming that God has not rejected His people.


We should also remember that theological disagreement about Israel does not automatically make someone an antisemite. There are sincere Christians who embrace some form of supersessionism without harboring hatred toward Jewish people. However, when Romans 9:6 is used to deny Jewish identity, justify hostility toward Jews, or claim that God has permanently abandoned them, Paul’s words have been twisted into something he never intended.


The irony is almost unbearable. A Jewish apostle expresses such overwhelming love for his people that he could wish himself cut off from Messiah for their salvation, and nearly two thousand years later, people use his words to argue that those same people are no longer Israel.


Romans 9:6 does not erase the Jewish people. It reminds us that God’s promises have always rested upon His sovereign choice and that physical descent alone does not guarantee salvation. And Romans 11 reminds us that the Jewish people remain beloved (v. 28), that God’s calling is irrevocable (v. 29), and that Israel’s story is not finished (v. 26).


God has not replaced Israel. He is in the process of restoring her.

 


 




Comments


Subscribe to our newsletter

Ron Profile Email copy.png

Here is a little bit about me. I serve as President of Shelanu TV, the only 24.7, Hebrew language TV channel sharing the message of Yeshua. 

I am a passionate advocate for Israel and desire to see the Body of Messiah have God’s heart for the Jewish people. I hold a master’s degree from King’s University and a doctorate from Liberty University. My beautiful wife, Elana, and I live in Israel and have three amazing grown daughters.

Testimonies from Shelanu TV—You are Making a Difference!.jpg
Book Mockup Vol 22 copy.jpg
I’ve known Ron Cantor for around 8 years. I’ve watched him take on a true shepparding role
bottom of page